Blog/AI In HR

Reference check questions that can change your hiring decision

Flowmingo Editorial TeamFlowmingo Editorial Team18 דקות קריאה
Reference check questions: a 20-minute call script: open questions that get polite praise beside the same 3 questions each rated 1 to 10

Your finalist aced the interview, you've drafted the offer, and 3 phone numbers sit in your inbox. The reference check questions you ask in the next hour decide whether those calls change anything.

Too many calls end in polite praise or a flat "we only confirm dates", because the candidate picked the referees and many HR teams will say nothing more.

If you call 3 referees for each of your last 3 finalists, at about 20 minutes a call, that is 9 calls and 3 hours spent re-confirming strengths you already saw, while the weak spot goes unchecked.

That weak spot is common. Among the finalists in AI interviews run on Flowmingo, which publishes this guide, about 4 in 10 had a job criterion the interview rated weak or never tested. A finalist here is 1 of the 3 top scorers in a job.

So an employment reference check is worth the most when it aims at the gap your interview left open, not at the strengths you already saw.

Key takeaways

  • Which reference check questions are worth asking? Ones aimed at what your interview left open. In 1 study of entry-level jobs, a 10 to 15 minute call rating 3 named qualities predicted supervisor ratings.
  • How much should a reference count against the interview? Less than a structured interview, since the headline figure rests on 10 studies from before 1984.
  • When should I call, and how many referees do I need? At the end: 3 referees for each of your last 2 or 3 finalists, about 20 minutes each.
  • What must I never ask a referee? Anything you can't ask the candidate, such as health, age or religion. In the US, age is protected from 40, and in California past pay is off-limits too.
  • How do I know the referee is real? Call the company's main number yourself. About 1 in 5 employees at large UK firms say they or someone they know used a fake-reference service.

1. Which reference check questions predict whether my finalist will do the job, not just polite praise?

Aim 2 or 3 questions at the gaps your interview left, and ask for a 1 to 10 rating on 3 named behaviours.

Generic "strengths and weaknesses" questions mostly return polite praise, because the candidate chose these referees. Structure helps.

More than 20 years ago, in a 2004 study at 1 service organisation, Taylor and colleagues had untrained recruiters run a 10 to 15 minute scripted phone check for 223 applicants to entry-level customer-contact jobs.

Referees rated 3 qualities, such as customer focus. Among the applicants who were hired, those scripted ratings still predicted how their supervisors later rated their performance.

The questions should ask about behaviour, because someone who watched the candidate work judges it better than the candidate does.

A 2011 meta-analysis by Oh, Wang and Mount, now more than 15 years old, found that observers' ratings of personality predict job performance better than self-ratings.

Behaviour questions also catch inflated claims. Say your finalist claimed renewals on 40 accounts (illustrative, not customer data), and question 3 of the script below asks her old manager how much of that work was hers.

If the manager says about 25, you have a specific gap between her claim and her manager's account, and you can ask her about the other 15 accounts before you decide.

An overall 1 to 10 rating is a core reference question in Who, a hiring book by Geoff Smart and Randy Street. Ask for it on 3 named behaviours, then add our own "What would have made it a 10?", and the answers become comparable, as in our pre-screening interview questions.

Here is a reference check template. Open with: "Thanks for your time. I'm [name], hiring a [role]. [Candidate] agreed we could call. It takes about 20 minutes, and I'll use your answers only for this hiring decision."

Pick the 3 behaviours from the job's must-haves, such as dependability or handling unhappy customers.

  1. Verify: How do you know [candidate], and for how long?
  2. Verify: What was their title and main job then?
  3. Probe the gaps: What was [candidate]'s own part in [area, e.g. renewals]? How much of it was theirs?
  4. Probe the gaps: We didn't see [criterion]. Can you give me 1 time they [situation]?
  5. Rate: From 1 to 10, how do you rate them on [behaviour 1]? What would have made it a 10?
  6. Rate: The same for [behaviour 2], then [behaviour 3].
  7. Rate: Among people you've managed or worked with in that role, where do they rank?
  8. Pressure: What were their biggest areas for improvement back then?
  9. Close: Would you hire them again into the same kind of role?
  10. Close: Who else should I speak to?

Questions 3 and 4, the gap probes, matter most, because only your interview can tell you where the gaps are. All 10 questions fit the 5 steps of a 20-minute call in the figure below, with question 8, on areas for improvement, asked after the ratings.

Reference check questions in a 20-minute call: open, verify, probe the interview's gaps, rate 3 behaviours, close

Reference call structure: open on the role and how you'll use the answers, then verify. Probe the gaps, rate 3 behaviours from 1 to 10, then close.

How Flowmingo helps

Flowmingo has no reference-check feature. Its AI Interviewer, a structured, spoken interview each applicant does in their own time, returns a report that helps you decide what to ask.

The report scores each criterion 0 to 10 with a written justification, and lists 2 to 5 gaps. Replay the answer behind a low score or read its transcript, so you know which part of their past role to ask about.

Our tip, not a feature: turn the 2 lowest-scored criteria, or the gaps the report lists, into questions 3 and 4, in your own words.

2. Are reference checks worth my time? How much weight should one carry against the interview?

Yes, as a check rather than the verdict. A reference is a modest predictor built on old evidence, so your structured interview should outweigh it.

Schmidt, Oh and Shaffer updated the best-known summary of hiring methods in a 2016 working paper, now more than 9 years old. On a scale where 0 means no link to job performance and 1 a perfect one, it gives references .26, well behind a structured interview.

That figure rests on only 10 studies from before 1984, run "prior to the development of the current legal climate", so the authors warn it "may not at present be fully accurate".

A 2022 re-analysis by Sackett and colleagues, more than 3 years old now, then found older estimates for the top methods inflated, and ranked structured interviews first. Our structured interview guide explains that method.

What a reference does well is narrower. In 2013, more than 10 years ago, Hedricks and colleagues studied web-based checks that asked several referees each, and found the ratings predicted who the employer later let go, but not who quit.

Managers also act on what they hear. In a 2019 survey by the staffing firm Accountemps, more than 7 years old now, managers said they drop up to 34% of candidates after reference checks, as the trade site HR Dive reported.

So spend the call on the gaps, because that is where a reference can still change your mind. In the Flowmingo AI interviews below, about 4 in 10 finalists had at least 1 criterion to check.

For the 56% with no such gap, use the call to verify their claims and rate the 3 behaviours.

Flowmingo data · 1,458 finalist places · 486 jobs · 246 companies · AI interviews 22 Jul to 28 Sep 2026

  • 44% of AI interview finalists had at least 1 job criterion rated below 5 out of 10 or never tested.
  • 32% of finalists had at least 1 criterion that the AI interview rated below 5 out of 10.
  • About 17% of finalists had at least 1 criterion the interview gathered no evidence on. Some finalists had both kinds of gap, which is why 32% and 17% add up to more than the combined share above.
  • 56% of finalists had no criterion rated below 5 or left untested.

Finalists are the top 3 AI interview scores per job, not people hired. In jobs with 20+ scored candidates, the weak-or-untested share was 39%. These are AI ratings, not job performance, and untested means no evidence, not a missing skill.

The chart sets those 3 shares side by side, because a gap can be a criterion the interview rated weak or one it never tested at all.

Employment reference check targets: 44% of AI interview finalists had at least 1 criterion rated weak or never tested

Finalist gaps: 44% of 1,458 finalist places had a criterion rated below 5 of 10 or never tested, 22 Jul to 28 Sep 2026.

In practice, let the interview pick the finalist, and let references confirm it, flag a risk or break a tie. Set those weights on your interview scorecard before you call, so the call cannot quietly outweigh the interview.

3. Should I check references before or after the offer, and how many, from whom?

Check at the end, for your last 2 or 3 finalists, and in the UK as a condition of the offer. Call 3 referees each, about 20 minutes a call, including at least 1 former direct manager.

Timing matters because the call only pays off once few candidates are left. The US Office of Personnel Management, in its guidance on reference checking, puts the check "near the end of the selection process".

In the UK, Acas, in its guidance on references, advises asking "when making a job offer", and lists "suitable references" as an example of a condition attached to an offer.

If you check before any offer, tell the finalist, because a slow check can lose them to a faster offer. If a referee is still unreachable when you make the offer, make the check a named condition: our job offer letter template has the line to paste.

A 2005 report on federal hiring by the US Merit Systems Protection Board, now more than 20 years old, also recommends 3 referees, and checking more when their accounts don't match. So when stories disagree, add a 4th referee rather than picking a favourite.

Of the 3, at least 1 should be a former direct manager, because they saw the work and can rate it, while a peer mostly sees collaboration.

For example, 2 finalists with 3 referees each means 6 calls of 20 minutes, about 2 hours, against 9 calls and 3 hours if you check all 3 finalists.

3.1 The referee won't call back: is that a red flag?

Not on its own. A slow reply is normal, because referees are busy, and big employers often route the call to HR.

So make yes easy: 1 email with 2 time slots, then 1 follow-up call. For example: "Hi Sam, Maria named you as her manager. Could you spare 20 minutes on Tuesday or Wednesday morning?"

After 2 working days, ask the candidate to nudge the referee or name another former manager. Silence from every referee is the signal, not 1 slow reply. This is our advice, not a research finding.

Ask anyway: tell every finalist you will check references, and get permission before you contact a current employer. No country's rules stop you asking first.

In the UK, Acas says to hold a conditional offer and the applicant's permission before you approach a current employer.

The Information Commissioner's Office (ICO), in its UK GDPR guidance on verifying candidates, adds that you must tell candidates if you intend to vet them.

In the US, extra legal duties start when a reporting company does the checking. Obtaining a consumer report from one requires a standalone notice and written permission under the Fair Credit Reporting Act, or FCRA (15 USC 1681b).

When that company asks people about the candidate's character or reputation, the result is an investigative consumer report. Disclose it to the candidate within 3 days of first requesting it, and explain the right to request its nature and scope (15 USC 1681d).

In Singapore, the PDPC guidelines, from the Personal Data Protection Commission, let you take a reference from a former employer without consent, for an evaluative purpose. Ask anyway, because the candidate knows whom to call.

In the EU, Article 14 of the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) generally requires you to give people information about personal data obtained from others, including its source.

Its deadlines and exceptions depend on the circumstances, which makes it particularly important to check what notice you owe before you call anyone the candidate did not list.

At the final stages of your hiring process, call former employers first, and the current manager only after a conditional offer and a clear yes. Ask in 1 line: "We call 3 references before a final decision. Tell us who we can call, and anyone to avoid until you accept an offer."

A backdoor call to someone the candidate didn't list is legal in many places, but unfair unless you say you do it. Tell finalists up front, weigh 1 off-list voice lightly, and never use it to out a job search.

A recruiter on Reddit says backdoor calls were the norm for senior roles at their startup, and saw an offer pulled after 1 of them. How often that happens elsewhere is hard to measure, because off-list checks happen privately between people.

In a 2018 note on faculty searches at public universities, now more than 7 years old, Moon says the "veiled and covert nature" of these checks hides the extent of their use.

A backdoor call can also mislead you, because an off-list voice comes with no script, no known relationship and maybe an old grudge. Never let it outvote the 3 scripted calls.

Whoever the referee is, Singapore will limit what you can act on. Its Workplace Fairness Act, slated to take effect at end-2027, will bar rejecting someone over a protected trait a referee mentions.

The safe version is 2 lines in the invite, for finalists only, because a call the candidate was told about is no longer a backdoor.

Copy this: "We may also speak with people you worked with beyond your list, never your current employer. We will ask you about anything that concerns us before we decide."

6. Which reference check questions am I legally allowed to ask, and which invite a discrimination claim?

Ask only about the job: performance, behaviour, duties, dates and whether they'd rehire. Anything you can't ask the candidate, such as health, age, family or religion, you can't ask the referee either.

For disability, the US Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) says so directly. Its guidance under the Americans with Disabilities Act, issued in 1995 and more than 30 years old, bars asking a former employer any disability-related question you couldn't ask the applicant.

The question itself can become evidence, because the EEOC says questions revealing race, sex, religion or age "may be used as evidence" of intent to discriminate. In the US, age protection starts at 40.

In California, Labor Code 432.3 bars seeking salary history, personally or through an agent, so a referee call counts. Keep pay off every script, so 1 template works in every state.

In Great Britain, section 60 of the Equality Act 2010 bars health questions before a job offer.

Guidance from the Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC), quoted by Stammeringlaw, says that includes questions put to a past employer. So leave sickness absence until after the offer.

Use this table as the last check on your reference check questions before you dial.

Ask about Don't ask about
Performance and 1 specific example Health, disability, sick days
Duties, title and dates Race, colour, national origin, religion
Would you rehire them Age, or clues like graduation year
How they handled feedback Marriage, pregnancy, children, caregiving
Reason they left Past pay or benefits

If a referee volunteers something protected, such as "she was out a lot with her kids", stop them politely and don't write it down.

7. The old employer only confirms dates: which reference check questions still get a useful answer?

Treat "dates only" as neutral, confirm the facts, then ask a former direct manager for their own view. A referee may still answer the rehire question, and in California the law protects that answer.

A referee may limit an answer because of employer policy or concern about disputes. Ask which job-related facts they can confirm, and record the limits of the answer rather than treating silence as a negative reference.

In California, that rehire answer has legal cover. Civil Code 47(c) protects performance facts "based upon credible evidence, made without malice", and the answer to whether the employer would rehire.

Dates are not what most managers want from a reference, either. In the same Accountemps survey of more than 2,800 senior managers, 38% most wanted strengths and weaknesses, and 22% descriptions of past duties.

Titles and dates came third, ahead of only preferred work culture.

What managers want from a reference check: strengths and weaknesses 38%, past duties 22%, titles and dates 19%

Managers' wish list: 38% most want strengths and weaknesses, 22% past duties, 19% titles and dates, 12% work culture (Accountemps survey from 2019, more than 7 years old).

So a dates-only answer covers the third item on that list and misses the 2 that managers ranked highest. Confirm dates and title, then ask "Is she eligible for rehire?"

Then ask the candidate for the former manager's direct contact, or a peer or client, who can speak to the rest.

7.1 Can I legally give an honest bad reference for a former employee?

It depends on jurisdiction and circumstances. In the UK, a reference must be "accurate and fair", says Acas, and "there should be evidence to support the opinion".

When you are the one calling, that standard shows what to ask for: first-hand, job-related facts and the examples behind them. Keep accurate notes and explain their use.

Legal protections vary by jurisdiction, so promise the referee neither immunity nor complete confidentiality. Keep the ask narrow, for example: "I'm only asking what you saw her do on renewals."

When you are the one giving the reference, never make it falsely negative to punish an equal-opportunity complaint: the EEOC treats that as retaliation.

8. How do I spot a fake or AI-written reference before I make the offer?

Verify the referee before you trust the reference, because a written letter alone no longer proves a real person wrote it.

The voice on the phone may not be who the candidate says, either. For its Workplace Fraud Trends 2025 report, Cifas, a UK not-for-profit fraud prevention service, surveyed 2,000 employees at UK firms with 1,000+ staff.

Almost a fifth (19%) said they or someone they know used a fake "reference house" to cover gaps in their employment.

Nor does a written letter settle it. In a 2025 single-blind trial by Simister and colleagues, 7 faculty reviewers from 4 residency programmes graded 45 letters of recommendation.

People wrote a third of them, and the AI tools ChatGPT and Google Bard wrote the rest. The reviewers correctly identified only 40% of the letters people wrote and 63% of the AI-written ones. In other words, they took 6 in 10 real letters for AI.

Fake reference check risk: reviewers judged only 40% of human-written letters human and spotted 63% of AI-written ones

AI letter test: reviewers judged only 40% of the letters people wrote to be human, and spotted 63% of AI-written ones, in a single-blind trial of 45 letters.

Those were residency letters, not job references, but the lesson carries.

AI drafts can also invent detail and add gender stereotypes. In a 2023 study, more than 2 years old now, Wan and colleagues found gender bias in reference letters written by ChatGPT and the AI model Alpaca, and more of it in the detail the models invented.

Before any reference check questions, run these checks:

  1. Call the employer's main number and ask for the referee by name.
  2. Check their role on the company site or a public profile.
  3. Talk live: a letter is a lead, not proof.
  4. If a step fails, ask for another former manager.

8.1 Should I switch to an online form or an AI reference tool?

Use forms for speed, and keep a live call for your final pick. In Hedricks and colleagues' study of web-based checks, cited earlier, web forms sent to several referees came back faster and more often.

Say you have 2 finalists: send a web form to their 6 referees, then book a 20-minute live call with your final pick's former manager.

A form is easier to fake and harder to probe, because nobody hears the voice, checks the number or follows up a vague answer.

An AI reference tool can bring legal duties of its own. In the UK, if software makes the decision on its own, the ICO says to tell candidates and offer a human review.

In the EU, the AI Act, the law that sets rules for AI systems, lists an AI tool that evaluates candidates as high-risk, and Regulation (EU) 2026/1744 moved the start of those high-risk duties to 2 December 2027.

9. One finalist's references glow, the other's are lukewarm: should a vague reference change my decision?

Not on tone alone. A lukewarm reference should change your decision only when it confirms a gap you already saw, or when 2 referees raise the same concern.

Glowing praise can say more about the referee than the candidate. In a 1998 study, now more than 25 years old, Judge and Higgins found that upbeat writers wrote more favourable reference letters, so a glowing tone can be habit.

Lukewarm can be a warning, since Smart and Street, the authors of Who, call "the absence of enthusiasm" a "terrible sign". But a careful referee sounds the same, so probe before you conclude.

The decoder below pairs 5 common answers with a follow-up. For example, "She was fine" with no example calls for 1 specific time, and a pause before rehire calls for "Would you hire them again yourself?".

Reference check answers decoded: faint praise, a pause on rehire, a dates-only policy, a 7 out of 10, praise for everything

Answer decoder: 5 common reference answers, from faint praise to a 7 out of 10, each with a follow-up question.

A dates-only policy is neutral, so ask for another referee. A 7 out of 10 earns "What would have made it a 10?", and constant praise earns a ranking question.

Then score both finalists the same way (illustrative, not customer data):

Question Referee 1 (former manager) Referee 2 (peer) Referee 3 (earlier manager) Average
Dependability, 1 to 10 8 9 7 8.0
Handling unhappy customers, 1 to 10 7 8 5 6.7
Working with sales, 1 to 10 8 7 8 7.7

Referee 3's 5 on unhappy customers sits 2+ points below the others, so call again or add a 4th referee.

How Flowmingo helps

Flowmingo's built-in applicant tracking system (ATS) has team notes and ratings on each candidate. Our tip, not a feature: type each referee's 3 ratings there by hand, beside the interview score.

Even strong candidates are uneven, as the card below shows, so a lukewarm rating on 1 behaviour is expected. It only matters when it hits a must-have.

Flowmingo data · 1,458 finalist places at 246 companies · 11,773 strong scorers at 502 companies · AI interviews 22 Jul to 28 Sep 2026

  • 3.5 points out of 10 was the median gap between a finalist's best and worst criterion.
  • 28.0% of the 11,773 candidates who scored 7 or more overall still had a criterion below 5.

AI interview ratings against each job's own criteria, not job performance. A gap means less evidence for 1 criterion, not that the candidate can't do it.

For example, say finalist A glows but scored lower on the must-have, while B is lukewarm on 1 behaviour the interview also flagged. Decide on the must-have first, then use B's references to plan B's first 90 days.

10. Hiring in the UK, EU or Singapore: which reference check questions and data rules apply?

The same job-related questions work in all 4 places in this guide. What changes is the notice you owe before the call, what the candidate may see afterwards, and what you must not ask about or act on.

The table below gives the US, UK, EU and Singapore 1 row each, and the cross-border case and the EU deadlines follow it.

The US leans on notice and state law, the UK on a conditional offer, the EU on notice, and Singapore on its evaluative-purpose consent exception, which is not a blanket data-protection exemption.

Where Before you call Can the candidate see it Don't ask or act on
US Tell the finalist; FCRA notice and permission for consumer reports Applicable law; FCRA report-copy rights for covered reports What you can't ask the candidate
UK Conditional offer; permission for a current employer Not if given in confidence Health before the offer
EU Explain the planned checks; provide Article 14 information where required Generally, access to their personal data under Article 15, subject to applicable restrictions and others' rights What you can't lawfully ask the candidate
Singapore Evaluative-purpose consent exception Not opinions kept only to evaluate them Protected traits, expected from end-2027

Access need not mean an unredacted reference. The EDPB's Article 15 guidance, from the European Data Protection Board, explains how to protect others' rights without a blanket refusal.

Singapore's rule that opinions formed about an applicant need not be shown to them is in the PDPC guidelines, para 6.10.

A team hiring across borders can't reuse 1 consent line. Say your team in Singapore is hiring for an office in Berlin, and the finalist's referees are former colleagues from her last job, in Munich.

Singapore's consent exception does not travel with your team, because it does not replace applicable EU requirements. Where GDPR Article 14 applies, it generally requires transparency for references, with exceptions.

Provide the information within a reasonable period, at most 1 month after obtaining the data. First communication or disclosure can bring an earlier deadline, and the exceptions include information the candidate already has.

10.1 Can the candidate or the hiring manager see what the referee said?

Restrict notes to decision-makers. In the US, whether a candidate can see notes from a call you made yourself depends on applicable law and your own policy.

For consumer reports, the FCRA also requires a report copy and a summary of rights before adverse action, then the adverse-action notice. So never promise secrecy.

The hiring manager needs the notes because unseen evidence cannot inform the decision. A candidate may later request them.

So write notes as job facts and ratings, not quotes: "Referee 3, earlier manager: 5 of 10 on unhappy customers."

In the UK, mark your request "in confidence", because the ICO exempts only confidential references from access requests, in guidance now under review. This is general information, not legal advice.

How Flowmingo helps

Send every applicant an AI interview scored on your criteria, then take its gaps into the call. Try Flowmingo before your next round of reference check questions.

11. Sources

Every study, law and survey in this guide links to a source below. Flowmingo figures come from Flowmingo's own AI interview records.

הירשמו והתחילו תוך כ-60 שניות. בלי כרטיס אשראי, בלי שיחה

הירשמו בחינם
Flowmingo Editorial Team

Flowmingo Editorial Team

We write practical guides for recruiters and HR teams who want to hire faster and more fairly. Each guide draws on hiring research, employment rules and Flowmingo's own data from real interviews, and lists its sources.

LinkedInYouTubeFacebook