Blog/AI In HR

How to write a job description that every hiring step can use

Flowmingo Editorial TeamFlowmingo Editorial Team18 min Lesezeit
How to write a job description every hiring step can use: a job description feeding the CV screen, the interview and the scorecard

You have until Friday, so you paste last year's posting and add 3 requirements. At many firms, how to write a job description means exactly that, and the fault lies less with you than with the template.

A job description template gives you the parts, such as the title, the duties and the requirements, but not which 4 to 6 criteria a CV must show. So the old list survives, and every new line goes on top of it.

The habit is common. Hidden Workers, a 2021 report now over 5 years old, by Harvard Business School and Accenture, surveyed 2,275 executives in the US, UK and Germany. For a middle-skills role, 72% of the employers reused or lightly edited an old posting.

The people they hired show how much of that list was padding. In the same survey, 47% of leaders said half or fewer of their middle-skills hires met every posted requirement, which suggests many of those requirements were never real must-haves.

That matters, because every line you add becomes a rule later: CV screening, interview questions and the scorecard all come from this 1 document.

Some of those rules work against you. In that report, 94% of employers using screening software said it at least sometimes screens out qualified middle-skills candidates who miss the exact criteria. That is a belief, not a measured rate.

So the real work is sorting your lines into must-haves a CV can show and lines that are there only because last year's posting had them.

Flowmingo, the company publishing this guide, makes hiring software, so some of the figures below come from hiring projects on its platform.

Key takeaways

  • What do I write first? The 3 to 5 results the person must deliver in their first year.
  • How many requirements should I list? Score 4 to 6 criteria a CV can show. In Flowmingo's data, a longer must-have list made no difference: 18% to 19% of applicants scored 7 or more out of 10, whether a project had 2-3 must-haves or 8 or more.
  • Should I ask for a degree and 5 years of experience? Only if you can name the task each line stands for.
  • Is there a template I can copy? Yes, section 6 has one to paste and edit.
  • Do I have to post the pay range? In many US states, yes, and the EU rule is arriving country by country.
  • How do I turn it into screening questions and a scorecard? Give every requirement 1 score and 1 question: hard facts go in the application, the rest become weighted criteria.

1. How to write a job description for a new role when I'm unsure what it owns?

Start from what the job must deliver, not a list of tasks. Write 1 sentence on why the job exists and 3 to 5 first-year outcomes, then derive the duties and requirements from them.

The usual advice is to interview the person who holds the job today, but a new role has no holder to ask. Our practice is to ask 3 kinds of people instead: your hiring manager, 1 or 2 close colleagues of the future hire, and 1 peer at another firm.

Ask each of them about outcomes rather than tasks, because outcomes say what good looks like, and that tells you which requirements matter.

The same idea sits behind Who, a hiring book Smart and Street published in 2008, over 18 years ago. As quoted in notes on the book, it builds its scorecard on 1 mission line and 3 to 8 outcomes ranked by importance.

We say 3 to 5, fewer than the book allows, so that each outcome can carry a number.

Say you're hiring a Customer Success Manager for 40 accounts. The example is illustrative, not customer data, and the same role runs through the rest of this guide:

  • Mission: keep 40 mid-size accounts renewing and growing.
  • Outcome 1: renew 36 of 40 accounts (90%).
  • Outcome 2: onboard each new customer within 30 days.
  • Outcome 3: all 40 accounts have an owner and a renewal date in the CRM.

How to write a job description: a mission, 3 to 5 outcomes, then duties, hard facts and scored criteria

Job description from outcomes: a mission, then 3 to 5 outcomes, then duties with share of time, then 4 to 6 scored criteria.

1.1 Can I use ChatGPT to write the first draft, and what do I fix before I post it?

A chatbot such as ChatGPT can help with structure and wording, but not with substance. We found no study of AI-written job descriptions, so the advice here is practice rather than evidence.

Before you post the draft, delete any duty you did not write, cut clichés such as "fast-paced" and rewrite the pay and legal lines yourself, since sections 7 and 8 explain the rules those lines must meet.

Then read it aloud once. In a thread on Reddit's r/humanresources forum, 1 manager shared a posting that still held the chatbot's offer to make changes.

2. My hiring manager keeps changing the requirements after we start. How do I stop it?

Agree the criteria in writing before the role opens, and treat every later change as a new version with a reason. If one comes after scoring, rescore the whole pile.

Writing the criteria down first matters because people bend them without noticing.

Uhlmann and Cohen tested this over 20 years ago, in a 2005 study in Psychological Science. In 3 experiments, volunteers rated a made-up applicant for police chief or, in 1 of them, for women's studies professor.

For police chief, when the male applicant was the "streetwise" one, people said the job needed street experience, and when he was the "educated" one, they said it needed education. In the 3rd experiment, rating the criteria before learning the applicant's gender removed that gender bias.

A manager who adds a must-have after reading the first CVs may be doing the same thing without noticing. So run this 20-minute intake before anyone drafts:

  1. What must be true in 12 months for this hire to succeed?
  2. Which 1 to 3 things can they not be bad at? These are the must-haves.
  3. What can they learn in 90 days? These are the nice-to-haves.
  4. What would make you reject even a strong CV? These are the hard facts, pass-or-fail conditions such as core hours, each job related.
  5. Who signs off, and when does the list freeze? Sign-off is step 1 of our hiring process steps, and every later change gets a version, a reason and a name.

The version rule matters most once scoring has started. Say 60 CVs are already scored when your manager adds enterprise renewals as a must-have (an illustrative case).

Save version 2, rescore all 60 and show the manager who moved, because a score only means something against its own criteria.

3. How to write a job description with must-haves clear enough to score every CV against?

Write 4 to 6 criteria a CV can show, with 1 to 3 Must Have (our practice). Ask 2 or 3 hard facts in the application instead, and write what a strong and a weak CV would show.

Then tag each criterion by how much it should count in the CV's overall score: Must Have, Very Important, Important or Good to Have. On the scale behind the Flowmingo figures below, they weigh 4, 3, 2 and 1, so a Must Have counts 4 times as much as a Good to Have.

The authors of Hidden Workers, the survey in the intro, also recommend a short must-have list. In our reading, that is because screening software enforces your exact words.

Write each criterion as scope plus proof, not a trait, because a trait such as "strong skills" gives you nothing to find on a CV. Here is the same role, rewritten (illustrative):

Line as often written A strong CV shows A weak CV shows Tier and weight
Strong account management skills Renewed a B2B account book and names its size and a result Managed accounts, no size or result Must Have, 4
Customer onboarding experience Ran onboarding for N customers and says what changed Onboarding as a duty, no change Very Important, 3
Proficient in CRM Names the CRM and what they tracked CRM experience, no tool named Important, 2
SaaS background a plus Names the SaaS product they worked with SaaS, no product named Good to Have, 1

Flowmingo data · 117,176 CV-screened applicants · 1,718 hiring projects · 827 companies · CV scores 10 Jul to 4 Oct 2026, older scoring method excluded · projects with 10+ scored applicants and criteria not edited after the first applicant was scored

  • 18.0% to 19.2% of applicants scored 7 or more out of 10 in the 1,647 projects with 2 or more must-haves: 18.0% with 2-3, 19.2% with 4-5, 18.9% with 6-7 and 18.1% with 8 or more.
  • 4 of 9 criteria were must-haves in the median project, and the middle half had 3 to 6.
  • 12.3% scored 7 or more in the other 71 projects, with 0-1 must-haves, where 64% of applicants came another way, such as by invitation, not through an open job post.
  • Among its open job-post applicants alone, the share was 14.9% (38 projects), in line with the others' 13.1% to 17.2%.

AI CV scores out of 10 against each job's own criteria, not candidate quality or hiring outcomes; 7 or more is the top band. A Must Have is a weight, never a filter, so this does not show that stricter requirements screen out more people.

AI drafts the criteria and recruiters may edit them, so 4 of 9 is the platform default plus any edits. How applicants arrive also moves the share, and scores do not compare across jobs.

Bar chart for a job description template: 18.0% to 19.2% of applicants scored 7 or more out of 10 whether the project had 2-3 or 8 or more must-haves

Must-haves and CV scores: 18.0% to 19.2% of applicants scored 7 or more out of 10 with 2-3 to 8 or more must-haves. The 0-1 group scored 12.3% overall but 14.9% among job-post applicants, in line with the rest.

One possible reason the share stays level lies in the arithmetic. Because the score is a weighted average, an extra must-have only moves weight toward that criterion and filters nobody out. We did not test this, so read it as association, not cause.

A tool that filters on your words works differently, as the 94% in the intro suggests. There, every extra line acts as a rule a candidate can fail, so keep the list short.

The typical project on our platform lists 9 criteria, more than the 4 to 6 advised here, so trim a long draft before you score anyone.

How Flowmingo helps

CV Evaluation, Flowmingo's CV screening tool, turns a pasted job description, or just a job title, into criteria you edit and rate by importance.

It scores every CV from 0 to 10 on each criterion, with written evidence. A criterion with no evidence counts as 3, and nobody is filtered out automatically.

4. Are the degree and 5 years of experience in my job description shrinking my pool?

Yes, often, and years of experience predicts little. Keep a degree or years line only when you can name the task it stands for, and write that task instead.

The degree line is the clearest case. In Dismissed by Degrees, a 2017 study now over 9 years old, Fuller and Raman drew on more than 26 million postings and found that 67% of US production-supervisor postings in 2015 asked for a degree.

Yet only 16% of employed supervisors had one, so the typical posting asked for a degree that the typical supervisor did not hold.

Years of experience fare little better. A 2019 review, now over 6 years old, in Personnel Psychology pooled 81 samples and found that prior experience tracked job performance at 0.06 across 44 studies, where 0 means no link and 1 a perfect one.

Dropping the line is not enough on its own, though. A February 2024 study, now over 2 years old, by the Burning Glass Institute and Harvard Business School followed 11,300 roles at large US firms.

It found that about 45% of the firms that dropped a degree requirement did so in name only. Where the line was dropped, the share of hires without a degree rose about 3.5 points on average, but only 3.6% of roles dropped it.

Across all roles, the net change was 0.14 points, fewer than 1 in 700 hires. This means a new ad alone changes little, so next to each line you drop, write the evidence you want instead and score for it.

The law points the same way. In the US, Title VII of the Civil Rights Act says a requirement that screens out a protected group must be job related and consistent with business necessity.

Lawyers say such a requirement has a disparate impact. Federal agencies are moving away from disparate-impact enforcement, but the statute and private lawsuits remain.

Great Britain's rule is close to it. In our reading of section 19 of the Equality Act, a degree or years line could be indirect discrimination if it puts a protected group at a particular disadvantage.

That would hold if the employer cannot show the line is a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim. This is our reading, not a court ruling or legal advice.

So before you keep either line, audit what it really tests (illustrative):

Line What it really tests Write instead
Bachelor's degree Can analyse data and write a plan Has written an account plan: a past plan shows it
5+ years of experience Has done the core task at scale Has run 20+ accounts, with scope and a result

Job specification requirements: 67% of production-supervisor postings asked for a degree, but 16% of employed supervisors had one

Degree requirements: 67% of production-supervisor postings in 2015 asked for a degree, but only 16% of employed supervisors had one (2017 study, over 9 years old, of 26 million postings).

5. How do I list essential functions for the ADA without creating a not-my-job excuse?

List the essential functions as results, each with a share of time. Write the description before you advertise or interview, because in the US it then counts as evidence.

This section is US-specific. The Americans with Disabilities Act, or ADA, is a US federal law on disability, and its employment rules cover employers with 15 or more employees.

Its section 12111(8) says a written description prepared before advertising or interviewing "shall be considered evidence of the essential functions of the job" (ADA text). It is evidence, not proof, so the work the person does still has to match the page.

Keep only the functions that matter, and move any task nobody would miss, such as booking team travel, to a marginal-tasks line. We suggest 4 to 6 functions, as the ADA sets no count.

For the same Customer Success Manager, the 4 functions share 100% of the time:

  • Own renewals for the 40-account book, including the work needed to close each one: 50%.
  • Onboard each new customer within 30 days: 25%.
  • Keep the CRM and renewal forecast current: 15%.
  • Resolve escalations before they reach a renewal: 10%.

To remove the not-my-job excuse, state the outcomes the role owns, as the first line above does. Add an other-duties line only if your counsel agrees.

The same list shapes your screening questions. Ask "Can you do [function], with or without adjustments?", never about health, because the ADA bars medical questions before an offer. This is general information, not legal advice.

6. Should the job description on file and the job ad I publish be the same document?

No, keep 2 documents: a file for the people who hire and a shorter ad for applicants, as 1 recruiter thread on Reddit describes it.

Each document has 1 reader. The file holds the job's outcomes, functions and requirements, and the ad is a pitch cut from it.

Here is a job description example you can copy for the file, built from sections 1, 3 and 5 (illustrative):

Job description: Customer Success Manager

Mission: Keep 40 mid-size accounts renewing and growing.

Year-1 outcomes: Renew 36 of 40 accounts (90%). Onboard each new customer within 30 days. Give all 40 accounts an owner and a renewal date in the CRM.

Essential functions: Own renewals for the 40-account book, including the work needed to close each one (50%). Onboard each new customer within 30 days (25%).

Keep the CRM and renewal forecast current (15%). Resolve escalations before they reach a renewal (10%).

Marginal tasks: Book your own team travel.

Scored criteria (strong CV; a weak CV shows the opposite): Must Have (4): renewed a B2B account book, with its size and a result. Very Important (3): ran onboarding, with what changed.

Important (2): names the CRM and what they tracked. Good to Have (1): names a SaaS product.

Hard facts, asked in the application: Core hours 9 to 6. Right to work here, where lawful to ask.

Pay: Grade [the pay band for this level]. Range to post: [lowest to highest pay you would offer on hire].

Adjustments: Can you do each function, with or without adjustments?

Version log: v1, [date], approved by [hiring manager]. Each later change: version, reason, name.

The ad's first screen holds the 3 results, 5 or 6 requirement lines at most, the pay range and what happens next.

It opens with a promise, "You will own renewals for 40 customers", and shows a typical week in 3 lines, not all 4 functions. Its requirements list, sometimes called the job specification, repeats the file's scored criteria, so applicants see what you will score.

6.1 How long should a job description be, and what do I cut so the must-haves aren't buried?

Keep the file to 1 to 2 pages and the ad to about 2 screens, because a long ad buries the must-haves and the pay. No source gives a word target, so these numbers are our suggestion.

Start with the verbs, and cut ambiguous ones such as "assists" and "handles", because they hide who owns the result. In the ad, also cut other employees' names, future duties, clichés and "other duties as assigned".

7. How to write a job description with a pay range when the law now requires one?

Post an honest range of the pay you would offer on hire, lowest to highest, never open-ended. In a covered US state or an EU country, check the rule first, because scope, dates and thresholds differ.

Even where no law requires a range, leaving it out can cost you applicants. In a survey of nearly 3,500 candidates that Gartner ran in May 2023, over 3 years ago, 44% said they had skipped a job in the previous 12 months because the posting had no salary.

How to write a job description with a pay range: 44% of candidates said they skipped a job with no salary listed, and 68% expect pay in the posting

Pay in the posting: of the candidates surveyed, 44% said they skipped a job with no salary listed, 64% are more likely to apply if pay is listed and 68% expect it (Gartner, 2023 survey, over 3 years old, self-reported).

An honest range can still be too wide to help. In 1 HR thread on Reddit, 2 colleagues disagreed over posting 122k to 128k, the pay on hire, or 101k to 152k, the whole grade, meaning the pay band for that level.

The grade spans 51k and the pay on hire 6k, so the grade is 8.5 times as wide and tells a candidate almost nothing about the offer. The law settles that argument in Colorado and California.

Colorado wants the lowest to highest pay you believe you may pay, so post the whole grade only if you would truly pay it. California wants a good-faith estimate of pay on hire, so post 122k to 128k there.

The table sets those 2 states beside the other places with a rule, as of 4 October 2026, and the list changes monthly:

Where Rule and start What it means for your range
Colorado Pay in postings since 2021, amended 2024 Lowest to highest pay you may pay; no "up to"; fines of $500 to $10,000 per violation
California SB 642 from 1 Jan 2026; 15 or more employees (Labor Code 432.3) A good-faith estimate of the pay you expect to offer on hire
EU Directive 2023/970, Article 5; deadline 7 Jun 2026 Pay or range before pay is negotiated, such as in the vacancy notice; no pay-history questions
Other US states The list keeps growing: Virginia from 1 Jul 2026, Maine from 29 Jul 2026, Connecticut from 1 Oct 2026 Check the state where the person will work, remote roles included; employee thresholds run from 1 to 50+ (Jackson Lewis)
Singapore MOM, Employment Pass jobs 14 consecutive days on MyCareersFuture; maximum at most 2 times the minimum

The EU row needs a caution, because a directive binds employers only through national law. By 23 September 2026, only 5 of 27 member states had fully passed it, according to the broker Lockton.

Poland and Estonia had partly passed it, mostly the pre-employment rules. This is general information, not legal advice.

Words about age, sex or language, such as 'young', 'waitress' or 'native speaker', screen people out. Describe the work and the proof of it instead.

The swaps below turn people words into work words (illustrative):

Instead of Write
Young, dynamic team A team of 8 that ships every 2 weeks
Native Mandarin speaker Speaks Mandarin with customers on calls: a short call shows it
Waitress, salesgirl, postman Server, salesperson, postal worker
Dominant, competitive rockstar Owns a renewal target and reports it weekly

Of those words, 'young' carries the clearest risk, because the US, Singapore and the UK all name it in their official rules or guidance. In the US, 29 CFR 1625.4, the federal rule on help-wanted ads, names it as a term that violates the Age Discrimination in Employment Act.

In Singapore, TAFEP, the Tripartite Alliance for Fair and Progressive Employment Practices, lists "Young/Youthful working environment" among phrases to avoid.

In the UK, the Equality and Human Rights Commission, or EHRC, names "young and dynamic" in its guidance on discriminatory adverts. That guidance, last updated in July 2024 and marked as under review, also lists titles such as waitress or postman.

Gendered words work more quietly. In a 2011 study, over 15 years old, Gaucher and colleagues found that ads for male-dominated fields used more masculine-coded words, for example "leader" and "dominant".

In their experiments with Canadian students, such wording made women feel they belonged less, but not that they lacked the skills.

The cost of getting it wrong differs by country. These words can break the law in the UK and the US, and in Singapore they breach the Tripartite Guidelines on Fair Employment Practices.

There, a breach of the Fair Consideration Framework can cost an employer work pass privileges for 12 months or more, according to the Ministry of Manpower (MOM).

In the UK, the EHRC can act on an advert even when no applicant was harmed, so a bad ad is a risk before anyone applies. This is general information, not legal advice.

9. How to write a job description I can turn into screening questions and a scorecard?

Give every requirement 1 score and 1 question: hard facts become application questions, and the rest become weighted criteria. The same list drives CV scoring, interview questions and the scorecard, so that you judge every candidate on 1 sheet.

The case for 1 list comes from research on interviews. Structured interviews ask every candidate the same questions and score the answers against a written rubric.

In a 2022 re-analysis of hiring methods, now more than 3 years old, Sackett and colleagues found that they predicted job performance at 0.42, against 0.19 for unstructured ones, where 0 means no link.

In our reading, they work best when the questions come from a written list of what the job requires, and results vary widely between settings.

The table below takes each scored line of section 3 and adds an interview question and an anchor, which says what a strong answer shows, ready for your interview scorecard:

Job description line Interview question A strong answer shows
Must Have (4): renewals Tell me about a renewal that was at risk. What did you do? A named account, an action and a result
Very Important (3): onboarding Walk me through your last onboarding plan. Steps, dates, what the customer did differently
Important (2): CRM What did you track in your CRM? A named field and a decision it drove
Good to Have (1): SaaS Which SaaS product did you support? A named product and a customer outcome

Each row follows the same rule: every scored criterion has 1 CV signal, 1 question and 1 anchor. Hard facts, the pass-or-fail lines, stay out of the table, and they fail a candidate only if the job truly cannot flex.

A weak answer is the opposite of each strong one, with no named account, step, field or product, and no result.

One more rule applies once software scores CVs against these criteria: some laws, such as California's and Colorado's, add notice, explanation or records, as our candidate shortlisting guide shows.

Job description example: 1 description feeds application questions, CV scoring, interview questions and a scorecard

Job description to scorecard: hard facts become application questions and weighted criteria drive the CV score. Each scored criterion gets 1 interview question and a scorecard line with written anchors.

10. My last job post drew many applicants and few right ones. What do I change?

Read the pile for the pattern: wrong applicants point to the title or requirements, and missing ones point to what screened them out. Change that 1 line, then measure the next batch.

If the post ran on a free board, check the board too, because a free post can sink in search or pause at a cap, as our guide to free job posting sites explains.

In a thread on Reddit's r/recruiting forum, a hiring manager at a large firm put a bold "no sponsorship" line in a posting, yet only about 1 in 10 applicants met the residency rule.

Text in a posting does not screen anyone, while a question on the application does, so move every hard fact into the form.

To find the line to change, read your pile with the figure below. Then run a 10-minute check (our practice): tick each requirement against your last 3 hires, and treat any that none of them met as a nice-to-have.

List of 4 weak-response patterns for a job description template, each with the line to check: the title, the must-haves and hard facts, degree, years and pay, or named tools

Posting symptoms: many unrelated applicants point to the title, and few qualified ones to the must-haves and hard facts. Skipped postings point to degree, years and pay, and mirrored CVs to named tools.

Before you blame the post, know what a typical pile looks like.

Flowmingo data · 117,176 CV-screened applicants · 1,718 hiring projects · 827 companies · CV scores 10 Jul to 4 Oct 2026 · projects with 10+ scored applicants and criteria not edited after the first applicant was scored

  • 11.5% of scored applicants scored 7 or more out of 10 in the median project, and 20.7% of projects had nobody at 7 or more.
  • 16.0% of applicants who applied through an open job post scored 7 or more, against 21.3% of those who arrived another way.

AI CV scores against each job's own criteria, not hiring outcomes. A project's numbers depend on its criteria and its applicants, so do not read 11.5% as a pass rate or a benchmark.

The 11.5% is a median of project shares; pooled, as in section 3, it is 18.3%. Our candidate shortlisting guide's 19.0% counts CVs from a wider set of projects.

In other words, a pile with few high scores is common, so it does not prove your post failed, and how applicants arrive moves the share.

10.1 Every CV repeats my job description word for word: how do I stop AI-tailored CVs gaming it?

Do not name internal-only tools anywhere in the posting, and ask for evidence a CV cannot copy from it. Numbers, scope and dates are harder to echo than a tool name.

Naming them invites the echo. In a thread on Reddit's r/managers forum, 1 manager got 3,000 applicants in 1 week for 1 IT role, and 75% of the CVs claimed experience with the internal products the posting named.

So a polished CV that echoes your posting proves little. After the CV cut, give everyone the same work sample or structured questions (section 9), because those test the work rather than the wording.

How Flowmingo helps

In Flowmingo's AI Interviewer, where each applicant answers your questions in their own time, you paste the job description, and AI drafts the interview questions and criteria for you to edit.

Once you know how to write a job description every hiring step can use, try Flowmingo to score every applicant against it.

11. Sources

Every study, law and survey in this guide links to a source below; Flowmingo figures come from Flowmingo's own platform data.

Registrieren und in ca. 60 Sekunden starten. Keine Karte, kein Anruf

Kostenlos anmelden
Flowmingo Editorial Team

Flowmingo Editorial Team

We write practical guides for recruiters and HR teams who want to hire faster and more fairly. Each guide draws on hiring research, employment rules and Flowmingo's own data from real interviews, and lists its sources.

LinkedInYouTubeFacebook